Svar: 11,784
Tråde: 233
Modtaget Likes: 12 i 12 svar
Givet Likes: 0
Tilmeldt: Dec 2011
Svar: 8,471
Tråde: 469
Modtaget Likes: 60 i 31 svar
Givet Likes: 18
Tilmeldt: Dec 2011
Vi har nu 12 på listen - og afstemningen vil blive sat op i to heat:
Heuer Carerra
AP Royal Oak
IWC Portuguese
Cartier Tank
Rolex Oyester Datejust
Eterna 3000
Heuer Monaco
PP Nautilus
JLC Reverso
Omega Constellation Pie Pan
PP. Calatrava
Zenith El Primero
vh Baun
•
hannover_dk Skrev:willy Skrev:I do not look down on Denmark in anyway.But i do mean that for example a Reverso or a Tank for that matter are bigger Ikons in the world of watches than any on your list.I mean half the world knows what a Rolex Oysterdate is and about less than 1% know what a Brietling navitimer is.The market prices tell the truth here.Take a look at the prices on your list and compare them with the prices on my list of watches.In my humble opinion the greatest Ikon in the world of watches must be the Rolex Submariner.No other watch has been copied like this watch.It alone created a Industry for sport watches.And the price for them vintage speaks for its self.Omega speedy is the most famous Omega in the world,thats it.But a speedy did nothing new in the watch world,so in my mind its not a ikon,and the same i can say about Brietling.These watches did nothing to change the face of watchmaking so how can you call them Ikons? JLC reverso is unique in the watch world so is the royal oak they created something new like the submariner and changed the watch industry.They are true ikons mr.Hannova. Willy. P:S I was not giving just my own opinion please try not to put words in my mouth about what i mean or do not mean.I never do that to you.You like me have your own opinion lets leave it at that
I would not put words in your mouth, but you do often express things as if you are the international guy knowing the international watch world better than any - and no doubt you know a lot. I think we largely agree - but maybe look at the word icon from different perspectives. Most icons in you world would be something that changed the watch world - and I think you would have to go back a long time to find them.
I have nothing against the reverso or the RO but maybe I do not find then great inventions as such - changing the world of watches - I find the submariner belonging there - and maybe the Eterna 3000 as mother to 100´s of brands of affordable watches - or you have to go back to the invention of shock protection, bimetallic balances and things like that.
I do not THINK Baun is looking for the biggest changes or inventions, or for what mr everyman things - but for what is icons in the eyes of watch people. In fact, the vote in it self shows that - with the speedmaster as one of the three. NOT because it changed the watch industry, but for what it was used for and the fascination. MAYBE it did change things - we cannot let what was done undone to check - but MAYBE Rolex with its oyster and Omega with its speedmaster did more than we know or think, to keep the wrist watch on the wrist even today
Calling a vote - as the one we have had - and its conclusion - not correct - or the result coming from people without insight - even if YOU disagree - is not right.
All the best - have a great saturday night evening Willy -
John
Citat:
Okay but i still disagree completly.
willy
•
Svar: 11,784
Tråde: 233
Modtaget Likes: 12 i 12 svar
Givet Likes: 0
Tilmeldt: Dec 2011
willy Skrev:Okay but i still disagree completly. willy
Your right indeed <!-- s:lol: --><img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_lol.gif" alt=":lol:" title="Laughing" /><!-- s:lol: -->
•
Svar: 5,076
Tråde: 304
Modtaget Likes: 147 i 89 svar
Givet Likes: 284
Tilmeldt: Sep 2005
Zenith El Primero opdager jeg nu er på listen. Det er da ikke et ur men et urværk eller hvordan skal det tolkes?
Mvh
Klaus
•
Svar: 11,784
Tråde: 233
Modtaget Likes: 12 i 12 svar
Givet Likes: 0
Tilmeldt: Dec 2011
KlausM Skrev:Zenith El Primero opdager jeg nu er på listen. Det er da ikke et ur men et urværk eller hvordan skal det tolkes?
Mvh
Klaus
Jeg har i alle fald valgt at regne det bredt, som alle vintage zenith El proimero (da det jo er fastsat vi taler vintage her) med elprimero kaliberen - og El Primero på skiven- og der står jo faktisk Elprimero på skiven, så jeg vil vel også betegne det som et ur - ud over et værk, men jeg er enig i der jo er lidt forskellige, dog ikke så mange når vi er begrænset til Vintage - eksempel på en ElPrimero - her Rainbow -. men kunne være DeLuca og andre vintage elprimeroer -
•
hannover_dk Skrev:KlausM Skrev:Zenith El Primero opdager jeg nu er på listen. Det er da ikke et ur men et urværk eller hvordan skal det tolkes?
Mvh
Klaus
Jeg har i alle fald valgt at regne det bredt, som alle vintage zenith El proimero (da det jo er fastsat vi taler vintage her) med elprimero kaliberen - og El Primero på skiven- og der står jo faktisk Elprimero på skiven, så jeg vil vel også betegne det som et ur - ud over et værk, men jeg er enig i der jo er lidt forskellige, dog ikke så mange når vi er begrænset til Vintage - eksempel på en ElPrimero - her Rainbow -. men kunne være DeLuca og andre vintage elprimeroer -
Citat:
El Primero one of the watch worlds greatest calibers ever.At last we agree on something mr hannova <!-- s:lol: --><img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_lol.gif" alt=":lol:" title="Laughing" /><!-- s:lol: --> <!-- s:lol: --><img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_lol.gif" alt=":lol:" title="Laughing" /><!-- s:lol: --> Willy
•
Svar: 11,784
Tråde: 233
Modtaget Likes: 12 i 12 svar
Givet Likes: 0
Tilmeldt: Dec 2011
willy Skrev:El Primero one of the watch worlds greatest calibers ever.At last we agree on something mr hannova <!-- s:lol: --><img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_lol.gif" alt=":lol:" title="Laughing" /><!-- s:lol: --> <!-- s:lol: --><img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_lol.gif" alt=":lol:" title="Laughing" /><!-- s:lol: --> Willy
I think we have done that often Ali/Wily - not always - but quite often
br
•